my own private I dunno: résumé | screenplays | fan fiction

To Google or not to Google...

| | comments (3)

A week ago, on February 22, Chris Pirllo, uber geek, decided to take a break from Google:

I've been growing increasingly concerned over how Google is starting to do more... and the world is just letting it do more without asking questions (because most users trust the brand blindly). Google is everywhere. I want it to be everywhere, but I also don't want it to be everywhere - because that's very scary. I trust that they will continue to "do no evil" (as opposed to "do know evil?") - but perhaps there's such a thing as "too big?" I have to prepare for the worst.

...

I'm going to live without searching for anything on Google (or using Google software) for a week... ohmygod.

You’re a better man than I am, Charlie Brown: I don’t know if I could do it. I’ve said for years now that without access to the Internet I feel like part of my brain has been turned off, but when I really think about it, it’s Google that makes my brain feel bigger. I mean, sure, there are plenty of other search engines out there, but Googling something has become so instinctive and automatic to me that to have to stop and think about where I’m gonna go to search throws a big ol’ spanner in the works.

Is Chris right, though? Maybe... There’s a Google seach box built into Safari, the browser I’m using, and there’s something a little insidious about that. Ask.com just killed Jeeves in an attempt to better compete with Google. When cartoon spokesmen are getting axed, has it all just gone too far?

How’s it going for Chris? He’s blogging the experience, of course, and yesterday he decided to extend his experiment for another week.

3 Comments

I actually only use google as a backup, searchwise - I've been a yahoo fanboy since before google was a name brand. I do use gmail as my primary *public* email address, but I could go back to hotmail if I had to. Hotmail makes me sad, but I could live. Anyway, I have two other email addresses that are way more important (from my school, and at fieldmusic.net).
I understand that google is trying to make themselves indispensible to us, but I have an increasingly sour taste for search engines in general. I am trying to design my house and every time I do a search for specific building materials I get thousands of porn sites and about 100 are ahead in the search list to the data I really wanted. I was searching for special concrete for wet earth applications. The porn sites apparently paid to be listed first in any search. However, it's hard to see how porn figures into wet setting concrete. So why is it even in my search, much less ahead of what I asked for? The bigger these search engines become the worse this gets. The advertisers are so afraid of being left out they keep upping the amount they pay for the privilege of being first. That seems to be counter productive for keeping people using your service. I hope google makes it wherever they are going, but I wish they would make some changes to the path they are taking to get there.
Well, in searching for "wet setting concrete", I believe the key term for generating porn results there is "wet." But Google doesn't accept payments to rank their results (other than the clearly labeled and highlighted one or two sponsored results at the top) so that's not what the problem is. The problem is that these sites spam comments in blogs and set up fake web sites and stuff to make it look like their sites are more popular than they are, and they stick up pages on their site that basically just list every word in the dictionary (especially all the naughty ones) so that they'll come up in any search. Google has pretty good algorithms to keep them off the top of the results, but it's not perfect, and it's always an ongoing battle.

Leave a comment


I'm MaryAnn Johanson, writer and editor, and this is my scratch pad, idea-jotter-downer, portfolio and resume, and general hang-out blog.

• film/TV/pop culture critic at FlickFilosopher.com
• contributor, Film.com
• member, Online Film Critics Society
• member, Alliance of Women Film Journalists
• member, International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences

[become a Facebook fan]
[visit my personal Facebook page]
[follow me on Twitter]


Location: New York City
[email me]

photo by David Speranza

archives

recently at FlickFilosopher.com

Powered by Movable Type 5.01

what I’m watching
(region 1)

what I’m watching
(region 2)

what I’m reading



my book
(Amazon U.S.)

my book
(Amazon U.K.)