my own private I dunno: résumé | screenplays | fan fiction

What is geek philosophy?

| | comments (7)

What is geek philosophy, and why do we need it?

Look, we won. Guys, we won. Some of the richest men in the world are geeks -- c'mon, people don't come any geekier than Bill Gates. The most popular movies and TV shows revel in geekery -- if the kids who actually liked high-school biology (I was one of them) created a TV show, it'd be CSI; everyone and their mom is seeing this new Star Wars flick -- even if most of the people who enjoy them would never define themselves as geeks. A scan of the help-wanteds demonstrates that every other job going wanting demands skills that we geeks were honing during our sad, pathetic teenhoods when everyone else was out at football games and sock hops or whatever the cool kids were doing in the 1980s.

So why doesn't it feel like we won? Because, despite the triumph of everything geeky, we are still rejected. Made fun of. Teased. Looked upon with a combination of revulsion and pity. It is time to take back the word "geek," to overcome our shame and our embarrassment, to stand up and proudly announce, "We're geeks, we're here, deal with it." It cannot hurt us to take a cue from our queer brothers and sisters (some of whom are geeks, too) and come out of the closet as happy, productive, weird human beings. For our weirdness is redefining "normal."

But this isn't just one of those ludicrous exercises in building self-esteem that ignores, you know, reality: Geek philosophy isn't about making people feel better about one's closest relationship being with a computer, or a complete collection of still-in-the-box Buck Rogers in the 25th Century action figures, or whatever stereotype of geekiness is in vogue at the moment (because of course there is a tiny minority of folks for whom it would probably be healthy to be a little less stereotypically geeky). It's about recognizing that there is value in the geek outlook and the geek aesthetic and the geek approach to life, and about putting the fact that the geek outlook is spreading into some sort of cultural context.

Okay, so why the focus on Generation X? ("Celebrating the culture of Generation X" is the blog's subtitle.) Of course there are geeks older than GenXers... but I'm not so sure the term "geek" has any meaning when applied to people younger than Xers. For though geekiness has always been with us, adult Xers have taken it mainstream -- a 15-year-old geek today, in 2005, is not a freak like a 15-year-old geek was in 1984, when I was 15, was. Geeky is cool, today... and Xers, in many ways, made it that way. In a similar way that hippies defined the Baby Boom generation even though they constituted but a tiny percentage of that generation, I believe that geeks have defined and are continuing to define Generation X -- if you're an Xer and not a geek, that's how you define yourself: as not-a-geek. Geekiness and GenXness goes together without saying.

Who we are -- as geeks and as Xers -- is going to have a dramatic impact on our culture as a whole, and it's starting in earnest right now, as Xers -- the oldest of whom are now 40ish -- begin to move into positions of authority and start to blossom creatively. I believe we're in for a new golden age of entertainment, of pop culture, produced by Xers... and it's going to be geeky. I'm gonna show you why that's something to celebrate.

7 Comments

Hello, Ms. Johanson! Stopped over here from Flick Philosopher. I can't really comment on the article because I'm not a Gen Xer (too young). As for geeky being cool today, I first I completely agreed with you (I try to fit in with the geek crowd these days >Hello, Ms. Johanson! Stopped over here from Flick Philosopher. I can't really comment on the article because I'm not a Gen Xer (too young). As for geeky being cool today, I first I completely agreed with you (I try to fit in with the geek crowd these days >
Newbia's got a good point. The word "geek" includes being outcast and rejected right there in its definition. There is no "reclaiming" to do with this word any more than one could take legitimate pride in the term "bottom-feeder." The most prominent use of the word "geek" before the eighties was in the phrase "circus geek," the poor bastard who bit the heads off of live chickens for a living. Maybe the lifestyle that was called "geeky" in the past has ceased to be geeky and has become part of the mainstream. Maybe we need to find a term that is more descriptive of this actual lifestyle instead of using the familiar pejorative. For that matter, the term "Gen X" was coined to describe our supposed lack of identity and commitment in our early twenties. (I think most of that came from Baby Boomers being appalled at how late in life we were getting married and the fact that there weren't enough street protests to satisfy the aging hippies during Gulf War I.) Isn't it funny how these generational identifiers are flat-out insults? There's nothing insulting about being called "Baby Boomers" -- reductive, but not insulting. And thanks to Brokaw, the previous crew are the "Greatest Generation." But us? We're the faceless, meaningless, puzzling Generation X. And how do you solve a problem like Maria? But for what it's worth, hell yes, I'm a Gen X geek. :)
I don't know about 'geek' and 'cool' fitting in the same sentence. When I stick to film: Harry Knowles is a geek. But I wouldn't go so far as to say that Harry Knowles is cool. How 'bout you, philosopher?
Pfft. Naysayers. I am a geek, even taking today's definition of geekiness and I am proud. Yes. I wear glasses. I like science and math. I even like anime and other geeky things. I don't see why people with glasses acne and pocket protectors can't be celebrated as meaningful, worthy human beings (as they undoubtedly are). If that's what celebrating geekiness is all about, then I'm all for it!
My concern is that the popularization of the "geeky" has lead to diluting it and dumbing it down. CSI's initial appeal for me soon waned after the scientific (and procedural) errors started to be come more frequent and glaring; it's still the most popular show on television, though. I guess it's the idea of science that's been made acceptable; actual science still doesn't get much play in the popular media. I remember when science fiction was about ideas ... if you ask people to name some of the best science fiction films of the last five years, they will trot out Lucas' space operas, or shallow pap like The Matrix, not actual SF films like Code 46, Primer, or Vanilla Sky. To some extent, yeah, I'd say that on the surface, some kinds of geekiness have influenced pupular culture ... but I think the reverse has happened, too, and somewhat to our detriment.
Mark's hit it on the head. Geek is cool, and the cool kids are geek-wannabes. By their very definition and species being, cool people are early adopters of trends - but true geeks will live forever!
Being a geek is a hard job. Really. My mum was geek, simply the best at school and when she entered the university, faculty of cybernteics she said Stop! I dont wanna be a geek! And...she missed the chance to upgrade herself. I was a geek at school and I broke down cos I wanted to prove everyone I am cool chick. Finally i missed a lot of chances. Now I do my best to get back to myself... yes clever smart me. So what I advise to all geeks: dont pay attention to anyoneelse opinion! Be smart and improve yourself every day! And you will win in this life. Lisa

Leave a comment


I'm MaryAnn Johanson, writer and editor, and this is my scratch pad, idea-jotter-downer, portfolio and resume, and general hang-out blog.

• film/TV/pop culture critic at FlickFilosopher.com
• contributor, Film.com
• member, Online Film Critics Society
• member, Alliance of Women Film Journalists
• member, International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences

[become a Facebook fan]
[visit my personal Facebook page]
[follow me on Twitter]


Location: New York City
[email me]

photo by David Speranza

archives

recently at FlickFilosopher.com

Powered by Movable Type 5.01

what I’m watching
(region 1)

what I’m watching
(region 2)

what I’m reading



my book
(Amazon U.S.)

my book
(Amazon U.K.)