my own private I dunno: résumé | screenplays | fan fiction

I am Jack’s stunned surprise

| | comments (8)

I don’t drive so much anymore. I sold my car more than a year ago, and now, when I need to get somewhere mass transit can’t take me, I use a Zipcar. Or I’ll rent a car the traditional way for a weekend away. I don’t miss car ownership one tiny bit... except for the fact that I don’t listen to the radio anymore. That’s something I used to do in the car, and only in the car.

But I don’t really miss that, either. We’ve got an awesome university station from Fordham here in the Bronx, but the commercial radio in NYC pretty much sucks. Who wants to hear the same damn Goo Goo Dolls song every hour, interrupted only by Jessica Simpsons crap and idiotic DJs and endless damn commercials? Not me... though I still can’t help but turn on the radio if I’m tooling around doing grocery shopping in my Zipcar. And so I was stunned when, on a recent weekend, one of the local corporate goose-steppers was playing Hall & Oates and Van Halen and Huey Lewis and Joe Jackson -- a whole bunch of cool stuff that brought me right back to high school -- as well as older cool stuff. Damn: they played a Carly Simon song. It sounded more like the Fordham U. station than anything I’d heard on commercial radio before -- they were barely even playing any ads, it seemed.

I didn’t realize it at the time, but I’d stumbled across the new so-called Jack format that’s popping up all over U.S. radio markets. This particular station was only doing it for the weekend before going back to their "all Goo Goo Dolls, all the time" format, but I bet they switch over entirely eventually, and soon. Because I knew the instant I heard this eclectic mix of tunes that it was a desperate reaction to the competition corporate radio is facing from iPods, satellite, and cable, all of which offer more selection and more control. (My digital cable at home offers something like 40 commercial-free channels of all kinds of different music -- I’ve usually got the Big Band & Swing channel on while I’m writing.)

Not that Jack is gonna save radio. Plenty of people can’t stand Jack, and justifiably so -- it still cannot replicate the genuine eclecticism of a real music lover’s CD or MP3 collection. And Jack has no more personality than the more-limited playlist its replacing -- I’d still rather listen to an interesting and knowledgeable DJ who is allowed to put together an engaging and diverse playlist, who’s allowed to play stuff for a reason other than "this new cloned boy band is on a label owned by the same corporate overlord as this station."

And satellite is making greater inroads. USA Today is reporting that automakers are starting to offer new-car buyers a choice of either XM or Sirius equipment in their new cars. (This VHS/Betamax type competition in proprietary hardware can’t last forever -- satellite radio will really take off when the same equipment can pick it all up... but that’s another discussion entirely.) Reuters is reporting that BBC Radio 1 will soon be listenable over Sirius... and if you’ve ever heard some of the spectacular offerings BBC Radio broadcasts, you know to be excited about this.

The narrowcasting and the niche programming we’ve gotten used to on the Web and thanks to toys like MP3 players are the cause of this -- people know there’s an alternative to corporate "entertainment," an alternative that’s hardly "alternative" in the sense of the word we’re used to. "Alternative" doesn’t mean "cult" anymore: it means "I’m damn sick of being told what I’m supposed to enjoy." And maybe radio will be forced back to its roots as a means of truly local broadcasting, one whose content isn’t dictated by MBAs in another city. Wouldn’t it be cool if we geeks brought corporate radio down to our size? It seems we’re halfway there already.

8 Comments

Have you checked out podcasts? Granted, they can't play all the famous stuff you've heard of because it's copyrighted, but they can play great stuff that you've never heard of because it's independent. Insomnia Radio is my favorite. (http://www.insomniaradio.net) Plus, Jason's a good guy and fun to listen to. http://www.musicpodcasting.org has a bunch of great shows, too.
Having adopted XM in December, I've listened to no FM radio in the last few months, so I haven't given the Jack ripoff in St. Louis a try yet. That said, it sounds like the same thing XM does on its decades channels and the early 20s channels (several CHR and Hot A/C channels, a love song channel, and a general adult contemporary channel) but on XM I get no commercials and I get Cinemagic, which plays just film soundtracks and cuts from the movies. You drive 45 minutes to see Revenge of the Sith while XM gives you twenty minutes apiece from Ep IV, Empire and Jedi and see just how damned awesome it is. That said, the one thing missing from XM's general channels are DJs. They have a few on their decades channels, but the other CHR and A/C channels are just jukeboxes with an occasional ID or promo, and it seems lonely. Sirius has jocks, and it makes a big difference.
Another podcast that I rather enjoy is Coverville - good for finding some interesting songs. I'll have to check out insomnia radios.
I also only listen to the radio while driving, at home there is the wonder of internet streaming radio. And amongst the multitude of selections is what is easily in the running for the absolute best music radio station in the world is KEXP 90.3 in Seattle, http://www.kexp.org What you were saying about knowlegable DJ putting together a diverse playlist . . . right there is some of that. The majority of their focus is new music, but is all good. They apparently have a huge listenership in New York and do live shows from there once a year. Also, they are listener supported, which means no commercials. And when they do have pledge drives, they're almost as good as the music.
My problem is that my knowledge of new music pretty much ended sometime around 1989.... Apparently, the "Jack FM" format is actually really good at the Toronto station where it originated. There, it's an interesting DJ-driven format, but in its flavor-of-the-month radio format, it generally just means adding 100 songs to a "Mix" station's old playlist - all of which have been focus-grouped to death so that there's no danger of any true individuality or personality coming out.
Having a 1 hour ride to and from work everyday, I still listen to a lot of radio. Mornings is always NPR. Afternoons is usually Atlanta's 99X ("Everything Alternative"). It is the closest to true "Alternative" that _I_ can get. That being said, it also depends on what one means by "Alternative." We also have a "Jack" (DaveFM). They play a fairly good mix of "non-mainstream" music but I would hardly call it "Alternative" in the music indie's view of the word. It's all a matter of choice. If I had my "druthers" _my_ "Alternative" would have a healthy mix of New Age, Celtic and Punk thrown in (yes, quite eclectic) but I would have to start my own "Alternative" station for that. For now I'll have to settle for the Corporate America "Alternative".
"Reuters is reporting that BBC Radio 1 will soon be listenable over Sirius... and if you’ve ever heard some of the spectacular offerings BBC Radio broadcasts, you know to be excited about this." Uhh. Don't get your hopes up about Radio 1. It's the youth station and as such plays mainly dance music and the same crap that you described above. Be more excited when you get Radio 2 (older, more varied stuff) and Radio 4 (talk shows, plays, topical news programs).
How interesting. We've got JackFM ("we play what we want") here in L.A., too. The only reason I ran into it was because it replaced one of my favorite stations, so it took over one of my presets. But I like it enough, even though I can totally see it as an attempt to get in on the random-playlist trend begun by iPods. It's just weird to know it's popping up everywhere else too. A friend of mine says it's a takeover attempt by ClearChannel, heh.

Leave a comment


I'm MaryAnn Johanson, writer and editor, and this is my scratch pad, idea-jotter-downer, portfolio and resume, and general hang-out blog.

• film/TV/pop culture critic at FlickFilosopher.com
• contributor, Film.com
• member, Online Film Critics Society
• member, Alliance of Women Film Journalists
• member, International Academy of Digital Arts and Sciences

[become a Facebook fan]
[visit my personal Facebook page]
[follow me on Twitter]


Location: New York City
[email me]

photo by David Speranza

archives

recently at FlickFilosopher.com

Powered by Movable Type 5.01

what I’m watching
(region 1)

what I’m watching
(region 2)

what I’m reading



my book
(Amazon U.S.)

my book
(Amazon U.K.)